diff --git a/notebooks/rank_zero_case.ipynb b/notebooks/rank_zero_case_curves.ipynb similarity index 100% rename from notebooks/rank_zero_case.ipynb rename to notebooks/rank_zero_case_curves.ipynb diff --git a/tex/setting-and-problems.tex b/tex/setting-and-problems.tex index c4fd2af3a22222a7af7e648f5251466b40af4cce..17a01fc2707c8966b689b85245002d365a828501 100644 --- a/tex/setting-and-problems.tex +++ b/tex/setting-and-problems.tex @@ -162,11 +162,10 @@ are equivalent to the following more numerical conditions: \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} -\begin{proof} +\begin{proof}[Proof for $\chern_0(v)>0$ case.] Let $u,v$ be Chern characters with $\Delta(u),\Delta(v) \geq 0$, and $v$ has positive rank. - For the forwards implication, assume that the suppositions of the Lemma are satisfied. Let $Q$ be the point on $\Theta_v^-$ (above $P$) where $u$ is a pseudo-semistabiliser of $v$. @@ -244,10 +243,47 @@ Therefore, it's also a pseudo-semistabiliser further along the circle at $Q$ (supposition a). Finally, consequence 4 along with $P$ being to the left of $V_u$ implies $\nu_P(u) > 0$ giving supposition b. +\end{proof} +\begin{sagesilent} +from rank_zero_case_curves import pseudo_semistab_char_curves_rank_zero +\end{sagesilent} +\begin{figure} + \centering + \sageplot[width=\textwidth]{pseudo_semistab_char_curves_rank_zero} + \caption{characteristic curves configuration for pseudo-semistabiliser of $v$ + with rank 0 destabilising `downwards'} + \label{fig:hyperbol-intersection-rank-zero} +\end{figure} +\begin{proof}[Proof for $\chern_0(v)=0$ case.] +Let $u,v$ be Chern characters with +$\Delta(u),\Delta(v) \geq 0$, and $\chern_0(v)=0$ but $\chern_1(v)>0$. +So $\Theta_v^-$ is the vertical line at $\beta = \beta_{-}(v)$, and +$\mu(v) = +\infty$. + +For the forward implication, assume suppositions a and b hold. +Let $Q$ be the point above $P$ on $\Theta_v^-$ where $u$ is a +pseudo-semistabiliser of $v$. So $\Theta_u$ intersects $\Theta_v^-$ at $Q$. +Suppose, seeking a contradiction that $\chern_0(u)=0$, +then $\Theta_u = \Theta_u^-$ is also a vertical line, +and must then be the same line as $\Theta_v^-$ to intersect $Q$. +This would imply $\QQ u = \QQ v$ and then $u$ would not destabilise $v$ at any +stability condition. +So we must have either $\chern_0(u) < 0$, in which case $\Theta_u^+$ is the +branch of $\Theta_u$ going through $Q$; or $\chern_0(u) > 0$, in which it is +$\Theta_u^-$ instead. +The latter case is the only one which could satisfy supposition b, about $u$ +destabilising $v$ going `down' $\Theta_v^-$. +Which then forces the configuration of characteristic curves shown in Figure +\ref{fig:hyperbol-intersection-rank-zero}. +The positions of the characteristic curves ensures the numerical conditions 1, 2 +and 5. The other conditions follow from the definition of $u$ being a +pseudo-semistabiliser of $v$. -The case with rank 0 can be handled the same way. -% TODO expand this case too - +Conversely, suppose that the numerical conditions 1-5 are satisfied, +then this forces the configuration of characteristic curves shown in Figure +\ref{fig:hyperbol-intersection-rank-zero}. +This ensures that $u$ is a pseudo-semistabiliser of $v$ at $u$ destabilising +going down $\Theta_v^-$. \end{proof} \begin{remark} @@ -295,7 +331,7 @@ The case with rank 0 can be handled the same way. \section{The Problem: Finding Pseudo-walls} -As hinted in the introduction (\ref{sec:intro}), the main motivation of the +As hinted in the introduction to this Part \ref{part:fin-walls}, the main motivation of the results in this article are not only the bounds on pseudo-semistabiliser ranks; but also applications for finding a list (comprehensive or subset) of